|
| |
| | Conciliarism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia |
 | | In the history of Christianity, the Conciliar movement or "Conciliarism" was a reform movement in the 14th and 15th century Catholic Church that held that final authority in spiritual matters resided with a general church council, not with the pope. | | | The word "Conciliarism" is used when subtexts of heterodoxy or heresy are to be subtly emphasized, and aspects of structural reform within the Roman church are to be downplayed. | | | While not involved in the Conciliar movement of the 14th and 15th centuries, the Eastern Orthodox Church generally agrees with the conciliarists that final authority resides with the church councils rather than with the pope. |
|
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conciliar_movement
(307 words)
|
|
| |
| | conciliarism - Hutchinson encyclopedia article about conciliarism |
| | Though some conciliarists drew parallels with secular authority in constructing their arguments and though their arguments were potentially applicable beyond the confines of Church government, 15th-century conciliarism remained an ecclesiastical issue. | | | Theory of Catholic Church government developed in the late 14th and early 15th centuries, during and after the Great Schism (1378–1417, when rival popes had seats in Rome and Avignon), claiming that ultimate authority should lie with the General Councils of the Church. | | | More influentially, however, the store of ideas first created in discussions of Catholic Church government were deployed in a rather different context – by proponents of Calvinist resistance theory. |
|
http://encyclopedia.farlex.com/Conciliarism
(548 words)
|
|
| |
| | The Importance of Sobornopravnist in Church Government |
| | Conciliarity is the key to unlocking the wisdom of the New Testament Church and Orthodoxy. | | | However, their orthodoxy is not that of the Conciliar Orthodoxy of the early church. | | | Conciliarity in Orthodoxy and the Independence of the Ukrainian Church: |
|
http://www.uaoc.org/conciliarism.html
(3902 words)
|
|
| |
| | The Council of Trent - Dr. Herbert Samworth |
| | While the theory of Conciliarism failed in not giving the Scriptures the supreme authority in the Church, the movement, nevertheless, sought to implement the principle that there is wisdom in a number of counselors. | | | Despite the passing of these decrees, the Popes of the 15th century had managed to outmaneuver the Conciliar Movement and, by the time of the beginning of the 16th century, it no longer held a position of influence in the Church. | | | The decree Frequens taught that such councils were to be convened on a regular basis to insure that Church Councils remained a viable force in the Church. |
|
http://www.solagroup.org/articles/historyofthebible/hotb_0010.html
(2664 words)
|
|
| |
| | With expectation we have waited for Ecclesia Dei (mayecc25.htm) |
| | The Conciliarists owe it to their new faith to root out and destroy the old Faith, while Catholics are in duty bound to refuse and to condemn the false new religion with all its pomps and all its works. | | | Now the old God-centered Catholic religion and the new man-centered Conciliar religion contradict one another, and as all wars are ultimately religious, so a contradiction of religions can only mean war. | | | But the survival of their new religion depends upon the destruction of that old religion which clearly shows Vatican II and the New Mass to be false. |
|
http://www.dailycatholic.org/issue/2003May/mayecc25.htm
(1578 words)
|
|
| |
| | The Public Square (November 1996) |
| | An earlier conciliar movement (Pisa 1409, Constance 1414-18, Basle 1431-38) was, inter alia, an effort to restore a measure of universality to the Church after a dismal century that witnessed "the Babylonian captivity" of a papal office that was virtually bought and sold by earthly powers. | | | These are among the words put to dubious use in the current round of conciliarism aimed at taming the Church and limiting the influence of this prophetic pontificate. | | | It is a fine irony that at this historical moment a new conciliar movement arises that seems determined to plunge the leadership of the Church back into the perpetual commotion of national and ideological factionalism. |
|
http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9611/public.html
(17268 words)
|
|
| |
| | Cor ad cor loquitur: 04/25/2004 - 05/01/2004 |
| | In short, the Conciliarism of the fifteenth century was a movement of conservative catholic churchmen, not radical revolutionaries. | | | It still, however, refutes his premise that conciliarism is just as orthodox as papalism in the "Western authority tradition". | | | By now it should be beyond doubt that the Protestant reform movement was deeply in debt to and impacted by the conciliar theory—which in turn means that the Protestant reform movement was an orthodox catholic movement in some ways which simply are not amenable to standard Roman Catholic arguments about “the Church” and “rebellion”. |
|
http://socrates58.blogspot.com/2004_04_25_socrates58_archive.html
(15720 words)
|
|
| |
| | Gallicanism - http://study.jcsm.org |
| | He declared that papal decisions could be reversed until they were ratified by the whole church, and he advocated faithfulness to the traditions of the Church of France (significantly, not the Church of Rome). | | | These attempted to clarify the theological justification of the Gallican Liberties by appealing to the conciliar theory and reasoning that Christ gave Peter and the popes spiritual authority but not temporal. | | | In the conciliar spirit a church council's authority would prevail over the edicts of any pope. |
|
http://www.jcsm.org/StudyCenter/BELIEVE/txn/gallican.htm
(591 words)
|
|
| |
| | [Gallicanism] |
| | W ten [conciliar] duch pewien kościół rada władza byłby zatriumfować nad ten edykty od wszelki papież. | | | [Conciliarism], [an] wcześniej wchodzą w skład od [Gallicanism], był ten spróbować wobec załatać ten naruszenie pomiędzy ten przeciwstawianie się frakcje w ten Kościół katolicki. | | | Tych napadnięty wobec wyjaśnić ten teologiczny usprawiedliwienie od ten Galusowy Uwolnienia przy błagalny do [conciliar] teoria i rozumowanie ów Chrystus dał Piotr i ten papieże duchowy władza oprócz nie doczesny. |
|
http://www.mb-soft.com/believe/tpn/gallican.htm
(500 words)
|
|
| |
| | PetersNet: Russell Shaw, The Battle Over Primacy |
| | The essence of conciliarism is the idea that either in extraordinary circumstances (moderate conciliarism) or in ordinary ones (radical conciliarism) an ecumenical council has authority over the pope; while Gallicanism (together with its cousins Febronianism and Josephinism) leans in the direction of national churches, functioning with a strong element of secular control. | | | Other elements of Vatican I's teaching are: primacy was instituted by Christ in St. Peter; it is transmitted in perpetuity to Peter's successors, the popes; and there is no appeal from a judgment of the Roman pontiff to some higher authority, such as an ecumenical council. | | | Vatican I's definition of papal primacy signaled the quashing, after centuries of conflict and debate, of the movements called conciliarism and Gallicanism. |
|
http://www.petersnet.net/browse/3218.htm
(2630 words)
|
|
| |
| | The Path to Truth: Ibn `Arabi and Nikolai Berdiaev |
| | From which follows the inexpressibility of Truth by means of discourse, given the accepted means of logical noncontradiction, another understanding of cause-and-effect relations, the recognition of the one-sidedness of classical logic, etc. | | | Transcendence is real, it is realized in a segment of temporal being that has a beginning and an end: immanence is also real as a state of eternal being. | | | A question arises: What is the relationship between these two "kingdoms," these two worlds, and what is their relation to Truth? |
|
http://www.iph.ras.ru/~orient/eng/pube/ianbe.htm
(8178 words)
|
|
| |
| | Council of Basle |
| | Because reform was associated with conciliarism, and the whole business was so discredited, the papacy went into the later 15th century believing that the matter was closed. | | | The conciliar movement was also gradually losing secular support, the source of its original strength. | | | In fact, his election discredited the conciliar movement as being schismatic. |
|
http://history.boisestate.edu/hy309/papacy/basle.htm
(450 words)
|
|
| |
| | Cor ad cor loquitur: 04/18/2004 - 04/24/2004 |
| | Many Protestants spend hundreds or thousands of hours in serious meditation on serious scholarly sources of Church history only to have it all blown off by RC's absolutely unshakeable implicit faith in whatever "the Church" happens to say. | | | And I've gotten absurdly uncharitable dismissal from most RCs of my inquiries into Realism and Nominalism, even to the point of your good buddy Dave Armstrong, the king of contemporary Catholic use of Realism as a historical hermeneutic, flippantly proclaiming that I have a "Gospel of Nominalism". | | | I don't expect Catholics to roll over and die because I say "Conciliarism", but call me a naive moron, I surely expected a lot more than what I've gotten. |
|
http://socrates58.blogspot.com/2004_04_18_socrates58_archive.html
(14405 words)
|
|
| |
| | Council of Ferrara-Florence - http://study.jcsm.org |
| | The council also negotiated reunion with several smaller eastern churches (the Armenian Church, Nestorian Church, Jacobite Church, and Eastern Rite Churches) and challenged the conciliar theory (see Conciliarism) enunciated at the councils of Constance and Basel. | | | The Orthodox leaders had difficulty, however, winning approval from the clergy at home, and all semblance of unity dissolved after the fall of the Byzantine Empire to the Ottoman Turks in 1453. |
|
http://www.jcsm.org/StudyCenter/BELIEVE/txs/ferrara.htm
(292 words)
|
|
| |
| | SSPXAfrica.com: The New Mass: Depth Charged |
| | The Conciliar Church authorities behind the New Mass were and still are in the grip of a whole false but coherent way of thinking about God, man, life and religion. | | | By modernizing the Mass he hoped to save the Church. | | | In the war of religions presently raging between Catholicism and Conciliarism, the new pseudo-Catholicism let loose by the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), the book recently published by the Society of St. Pius X, "The Problem of the Liturgical Reform, the Mass of Vatican II and Paul VI", is a powerful cannon-ball. |
|
http://www.sspxafrica.com/documents/2001_May/Depth_Charged.htm
(614 words)
|
|
| |
| | Answer |
| | With the promulgation of the Holy Father, the doctrinal content of the various councils is a part of the sacred magisterial teaching of the Church to which Melkites in full communion with the See of Rome give wholehearted assent. | | | Recent theological speculation has developed the concept of "communion of churches" with promising results for ecumenism and rapprochement with the Orthodox. | | | It would be a simple rekindling of the old controversy of conciliarism to suggest that some councils are less ecumenical than others. |
|
http://www.melkite.org/Questions/T-2.htm
(337 words)
|
|
| |
| | CNS STORY: Bishops' conference tradition 'here to stay,' Archbishop Dolan says |
| | Even those bishops who are critical of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops "much prefer to be part of it and work through it to bring about the reforms they feel may be necessary," he said. | | | "This was a pontiff with a very public vision, ubiquitous in his travels, indefatigable in meeting with his brother bishops, nonstop in issuing his own pastoral letters and statements, who relished the conciliarism of world synods and extraordinary regional assemblies." | | | But the archbishop said one reason for the passing of the "heyday of American conciliarism" was "the towering figure of the bishop of Rome." |
|
http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0405901.htm
(850 words)
|
|
| |
| | Antipope Clement VII |
| | Uncertainty over who the legtimate pope might be during the time of the Great Schism gave rise to the legal theory called Conciliarism, which claimed that a general council of the Church wassuperior to the Pope and could therefore judge between rival claimants. | | | Eventually it was determined that he would berecorded as an antipope rather than enumerated as a pope. |
|
http://www.therfcc.org/antipope-clement-vii-19777.html
(417 words)
|
|
| |
| | Glossary of Terms: Apostolic See, Apostolic Succession |
| | This special competence to establish and interpret scripture is the basis of the claim that the authority of the popes is prior even to the authority of Scripture. | | | The extent and limits of the popes' power was at stake in the medieval disputes over conciliarism, the position according to which Councils of the Church, or Councils and Pope together, constituted the supreme authority in matters of theological doctrine and canon law. |
|
http://www-personal.ksu.edu/~lyman/english233/g-apostolic_succession.htm
(366 words)
|
|
| |
| | With expectation we have waited for Ecclesia Dei (1marecc.htm) |
| | You surely grasp the primacy of souls, and the value of pre-Conciliar - meaning Catholic - spirituality. | | | But have you grasped the full depth of the religious war - no less - raging now for 40 years between Conciliarism and Catholicism? | | | Roman or diocesan Conciliarists are of course perfectly free to present to you their side of the case, and they may persuade you that the SSPX and those who think like it are proud, intransigent, divisive, lacking in charity, etc.. |
|
http://www.dailycatholic.org/issue/2003Mar/1marecc.htm
(1779 words)
|
|
| |
| | Glasgow University |
| | Conciliarism was the disputed doctrine that authority within the Church was vested in General Councils rather than with the Pope. | | | He was a strong defender of the papacy against the theories of conciliarism which were prevalent in Scotland even after the Council of Basle in 1455. | | | The determination that Glasgow should have its own university was conceived by Bishop William Turnbull after whom today’s Catholic Chaplaincy, Turnbull Hall, is named. |
|
http://www.rcag.org.uk/archives/H5.htm
(651 words)
|
|
| |
| | Comments on: The never ending search for Truth |
| | I have friends and relatives who say that it’s just them and God against the world. | | | I have friends and relatives who say that it's just them and God against the world. | | | As someone who has been Anglican and Roman Catholic before becoming Orthodox the issue of authority is also interesting to me. In Anglicanism I'm not quite sure where the authority lies, so I have to conclude that it's really a Protestant system trying to masquerade as hierarchal conciliarism. |
|
http://www.songofgideon.com/wp-commentsrss2.php?p=26
(201 words)
|
|
| |
| | Basel, Council of. The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. 2001-05 |
| | The Council of Constance had seen the rise of the conciliar theory, the doctrine that the ultimate authority in the church rests upon the general council, to which the pope must be subject. | | | The German king Frederick III (who was later crowned Holy Roman emperor) remained neutral, but in 1448 his pressure on the city forced the delegates to retire to Lausanne. | | | It had been the plan to have frequent councils, but that of Basel was the first of importance to follow Constance, that of Pavia-Siena (1423–24) having accomplished little. |
|
http://www.bartleby.com/65/ba/Basel-Co.html
(568 words)
|
|
| |
| | Our Sunday Visitor Newspaper and Magazines |
| | Eventually, though, it petered out, upstaged by the Council of Ferrara-Florence (1438-1435), convened in an attempt to reunite the Churches of East and West. | | | The Council of Constance decreed that a council should be held every 10 years to govern the Church. | | | Catholic humanists such as Erasmus of Rotterdam and Thomas More, the Lord Chancellor of England who was to be martyred by King Henry VIII, wrote constantly of the need for reform in the late 15th and early 16th centuries. |
|
http://www.osv.com/periodicals/show-article.asp?pid=353
(3203 words)
|
|
| |
| | ttt |
| | From a Protestant point of view conciliarism, though a step in the right direction in its rejection of papal authority, was not sufficiently; it failed to see that, while the church does have authority (Matt. | | | This marked the end of conciliarism as a movement, though its ideas remained influential for some time. | | | But they began to be disregarded as soon as another pope was elected, and were finally overturned by Pius II in his bull Execrabilis in 1460. |
|
http://www.matthew548.com/d-conc.html
(194 words)
|
|
| |
| | Printed Publications |
| | Provides a detailed guide for leaders of church discussion groups on Odyssey. | | | Gives an overview of the foundations and functions of ecumenism and conciliarism. |
|
http://www.masscouncilofchurches.org/printdocs.htm
(352 words)
|
|
| |
| | OUP: Conciliarist Tradition: Oakley |
| | Readership: Scholars and students of the history of religion; historians of political thought; historians of the Catholic Church; theologians. | | | 1 Christendom's Crisis: The Great Schism, the Conciliar Movement, and the Era of Councils from Pisa to Trent | | | 2 Gerson's Hope: Fifteenth-Century Conciliarism and its Roots |
|
http://www.oup.co.uk/isbn/0-19-926528-3
(634 words)
|
|
| |
| | Gerson diet |
| | Examines his view of conciliarism, and considers his mystical theology. |
|
http://www.serebella.com/encyclopedia/article-Gerson_diet.html
(437 words)
|
|
| |
| | ARG 61, 1970-80, 1989 |
| | Calvin's Attach on Nicodemism and Religious Compromise, in: ARG 76, 1985, S. Gunter Z | | | , Die Einführung des landesherrlichen Kirchenregiments, in: ARG 76, 1985, S. James V. Ortwin Gratius, Conciliarism, and the Call for Church Reform, in: ARG 76, 1985, S. Eugène H | | | Zwei Untersuchungen, in: ARG 65, 1974, S. Harry J. Erasmus and the Primacy of the Roman Pontiff: Between Conciliarism and Papalism, in: ARG 65, 1974, S. John B. Erasmus and Lefèvre d'Étaples as Interpreters of Paul, in: ARG 65, 1974, S. James Michael W |
|
http://www.phil.uni-erlangen.de/~p1ges/zfhm/afrg1.html
(4561 words)
|
|
| |
| | VITAL SIGNS: THOMAS MOLNAR |
| | Indeed, a name was given to these efforts—conciliarism, the most immediate and direct term that the Church could accommodate. | | | In short, conciliarism meant that the pope was not the single authority who assigns policy and makes decisions, because these decisions and policies needed for their validity and universality the contribution of the bishops and, eventually, of other officeholders, too (and not necessarily just ecclesiastics). | | | In fact, the very meaning of the council shifted, exemplified by the Council of Trent (1545-1563), where the debate concentrated on facing the Reformation and reorganizing the Church's internal affairs. |
|
http://www.chroniclesmagazine.org/Chronicles/October2001/1001Molnar.htm
(1942 words)
|
|
| |
| | International Catholic University: 18.3 |
| | The pope had good reason to fear that if he convoked a council right now that it might declare itself to be superior to him and he would be enmeshed again in the old question of conciliarism. | | | But there were a number of things that made the pope hold off and not call or convoke a council. | | | As we can see there had been a rogue council just nine years before in 1511 at Pisa. |
|
http://home.comcast.net/~icuweb/c01803.htm
(4710 words)
|
|
| |
| | [No title] |
| | The new alternative is Conciliarism-the ancient (but underused!) Church culture that brings people together for consultation "as much as possible" at all levels whenever decisions are needed or action is to be taken. | | | If Vatican II is the work of the Spirit, then its intentions are the Will of God-and God's Will must be done. | | | Many parish staffs I consult with model conciliarism. |
|
http://www.votf.org/papers/paper3.htm
(3357 words)
|
|
| |
| | The Apostolic Conciliarism of Jean Gerson - Books & Textbooks for less at BuyBooksCheap.com |
| | used book, used books, discount book, discount books, text book, text books, cheap book, cheap books, cheap textbooks, college books, used textbooks, The Apostolic Conciliarism of Jean Gerson, Ryan, John J. | | | Many books are available new or used, giving you the choice to save even more. | | | The Apostolic Conciliarism of Jean Gerson - Books & Textbooks for less at BuyBooksCheap.com |
|
http://www.buybookscheap.com/staticpages/649/0788504649.html
(194 words)
|
|
| |
| | EXTRA!: ACLS Announces Interim President |
| | Among his many books are: Omnipotence, Covenant and Order: An Excursion in the History of Ideas from Abelard to Leibniz; Natural Law, Conciliarism and Consent in the Late Middle Ages; and Community of Learning: The American College and the Liberal Arts Tradition. | | | He is the author of numerous books and articles on medieval intellectual and religious history and on matters pertaining to contemporary American higher education. | | | His most recent book (1999) is Politics and Eternity: Studies in the History of Medieval and Early Modern Political Thought. |
|
http://www.acls.org/exoakley2.htm
(342 words)
|
|
| |
| | Church History Timeline: 1300-1500 |
| | It is a high point for Conciliarism, the idea that the councils are superior to the papacy |
|
http://www.churchtimeline.com/white/late.htm
(295 words)
|
|
| |
| | Politics Ideology and the Law, 187882239X, £65.00/$90.00, 208pp, 1995 |
| | Scholars in the field of early modern Europe consider various ways in which contemporaries in different walks of life expressed their understanding of, and participation in, the political community, using new approaches drawn from cultural history, the history of ideologies and a resurgence of interest in the history of institutions. | | | Subjects discussed include institutional rivalries and how they complicated efforts to mount opposition to government policies; political thought and concepts such as sovereignty, conciliarism, and dominum; and how contemporary understanding of the political order was worked out in a cultural context. | | | The volume also suggests new directions for research. |
|
http://www.boydell.co.uk/7882239X.HTM
(249 words)
|
|
| |
| | Journal of Religious History Issue |
| | 1-19 The Council of Pavia-Siena and Medieval Conciliarism |
|
http://www.blackwellpublishing.com/issue.asp?ref=0022-4227&vid=25&iid=1&oc=&s=&site=1
(71 words)
|
|
| |
| | Halsall/Introduction to the Medieval World/ Class 25 |
| | elected Theory of Conciliarism - Nicholas of Cusa Councils every five-ten years 1423, 1431 Martin V worked against this 1431-49 - Council of Basle - drifted into open schism with the papacy. | | | Papacy then got involved in turbulent politics of Renaissance Italy E.g. | | | Now three popes Sigismund, HRE arranged a new Council -Constance 1415-18 -Martin V (1417-31. |
|
http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/lect/med25.html
(798 words)
|
|
| |
| | History of Political Thought |
| | Oakley, Bronze-Age Conciliarism: Edmond Richer’s Encounters with Cajetan and Bellarmine |
|
http://www.imprint.co.uk/hpt/hpt_20_1.html
(92 words)
|
|
|
